||दूरसंचार विवाद समाधान एवं अपील अधिकरण ||
Telecom Disputes Settlement and Appellate Tribunal (TDSAT)
||सत्यमेव जयते||
NEW DELHI

JUDGEMENTS / ORDERS - 2009

 

S.No Appeal/Petition

Description/Case Title

Date of decision
1

Petition No. 5 ©  of 2008

Hathway Bhawani Cabletel & Datacom Ltd., Mumbai.

Vs.

Swastik Cable, Mumbai.

18TH DECEMBER, 2009 
2

M.A. No. 90 of 2009

In

Petition No. 198 (C)  of 2008 (With M.A.No. 4 of 2009 )

Dish TV India Limited, New Delhi

Vs.

SUN TV Network Ltd., Chennai

18TH DECEMBER, 2009 
3

Petition No.151© of 2008

M/s Indian Cablenet Company Ltd., Kolkata

Vs.

M/s Dum Dum Cable TV Network, West Bengal

18TH DECEMBER, 2009 
4

Petition No.153© of 2008

M/s Indian Cablenet Company Ltd., Kolkata

Vs.

M/s Satellite Link, Kolkata

18TH DECEMBER, 2009 
5

Petition No.202 © of 2008

Friends Cable Network, Punjab

Vs.

Hathway Data Communications Pvt.Ltd.,

Hathway Prime Cable Data Communications Pvt.

 Ltd., Chandigarh and

Fast Track Cable Network, Chandigarh .

18TH DECEMBER, 2009 
6

Petition No. 146 of  2005

 

M/s. Bharti Televentures Ltd, New Delhi

Vs

Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd, New Delhi

18TH DECEMBER, 2009 
7

Petition No.58 of 2006

Tata Teleservices ( Maharashtra ) Ltd., Worli, Mumbai

Vs.

Union of India , New Delhi and

Assistant Director General (LR),

Department of Telecommunications, New Delhi .

18TH DECEMBER, 2009 
8

Petition No. 58  © of 2008

(With MA No.141 of 2008)

 

ESPN Software India Pvt. Ltd., Gurgaon

Vs.

Bankey Bihari Communication, Haryana,

Ashok Sharma ,

Mr. Mohan Sharma and Surinder Garg, Haryana

 

18TH DECEMBER, 2009 
9

Petition No.153 © of 2009

(With M.A. No.156 of 2009)

M/s. Asainet Satellite Communications Ltd, Kerala.

Vs.

ESPN Software India Pvt. Ltd, New Delhi

18TH DECEMBER, 2009 
10

Petition No. 40 ©  of 2009

( M.A. No. 94 of 2009 )

Intermedia Cable Communication Pvt. Ltd., Pune

Vs.

Zee Turner Ltd., Nodia

Zee News Ltd., Mumbai, and

Zee Entertainment Enterprises Ltd., Mumbai

16TH DECEMBER 2009
11

Petition No.262 ©of 2009

Shree Communications, Andhra Pradesh and

SVS Cable Network, Andhra Pradesh

Vs

Star Den Media Services Pvt.Ltd., New Delhi

 

10TH DECEMBER, 2009 

 

12

Petition No.129 © of 2009

M/s. Friends Cables, Tamil Nadu

            Vs.

Star Den Media Services Pvt. Ltd., Chennai

 

4th DECEMBER, 2009
13

Petition No.149 © of 2009

 

M/s Vijay Communications, Krishna (A.P)

Vs.

Ushodaya Enterprises, Hyderabad , (A.P)

27TH NOVEMBER, 2009 
14

Petition No. 145© of 2009

Mona Cable Network, Saharanpur (U.P)

Vs.

ESPN Software India Private Ltd,

New Delhi

20TH NOVEMBER, 2009 
15

Petition No.123  of  2008

Cellular Operators Association of India , New Delhi ,

Bharti Airtel Ltd., New Delhi ,

Bharti Hexacom Ltd., New Delhi ,

Idea Cellular Ltd., Gandhinagar,

Reliance Telecom Ltd., Mumbai,

Spice Communication Ltd., New Delhi ,

Vodafone Essar Cellular Ltd., Coimbatore.,

Vodafone Essar Gujarat Ltd., Gujarat.,

Vodafone Essar Ltd., Mumbai and

Vodafone Essar Digilink Ltd., New Delhi .

Vs.

Department of Telecommunications, New Delhi

and Assistant Director General (WR), New Delhi

19TH NOVEMBER, 2009 
16

R.A. No. 5 of 2008 and

  M.A. No. 155 of 2008

            In

Petition No. 129 of 2007

Tata Sky, Mumbai, Maharashtra .

Vs.

Union of India , New Delhi and

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India , New Delhi .

4TH SEPTEMBER, 2009
17 Petition No.99 (C) of 2005

Hathway Media Vision (P) Ltd. Mumbai

Vs

M/s Spider Cable, Mumbai

28TH MAY, 2009  
18

Appeal No. 1 of 2008

(With M.A. No. 30 of 2008)

Tata Teleservices Ltd., New Delhi .

Vs.

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India. ,   

New Delhi .

13TH MAY, 2009 
19 Appeal No. 7 of 2007
(With M.A.No.158 of 2007)

Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited, New Delhi .

Vs.

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India , New Delhi .

13TH MAY, 2009 
20 Appeal No.10 (C) of 2008

M/s. ESPN Software India Pvt. Ltd., Gurgaon

Vs.

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India , New Delhi

13TH MAY, 2009 
21

Petition No.209 (C) of 2008

(With M.A. Nos.196 of 2008

 & 22 of 2009)

Hathway Cable and Datacom Ltd., New Delhi

Vs.

Neo Sports Broadcast Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi

13TH MAY, 2009 
22 Appeal No. 11 (C) of 2006

Wire & Wireless ( India ) Ltd., Industrial Area, Delhi

Vs.

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India , New Delhi and

Cable Operators Federation of India

12TH MAY, 2009 
23

Appeal No.6 of 2006

        Along  With

Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd., New Delhi

Vs.

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India , New Delhi ,

Association of Unified Telecom Service

 Providers of India (AUSPI), New Delhi and

Cellular Operators Association of India ,  New Delhi .

12TH MAY, 2009 
24 Appeal No. 5 of 2007

Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd., New Delhi .

Vs.

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India , New Delhi ,

Association of Unified Telecom Servic

Providers of India (AUSPI) New Delhi ,

Reliance Communications Ltd., New Delhi ,

Tata Teleservices Ltd., New Delhi ,

HFCL Infotel Ltd., Punjab ,

Cellular Operators Association of India ,

New Delhi, Aircel Limited, Chennai,

BPL Mobile Communications Ltd., Mumbai,

Bharti Televentures Ltd., New Delhi ,

Idea Cellular Ltd., Gandhi Nagar,

Hutchison Essar Sout Ltd., New Delhi ,

Aircel Digilink India Ltd., (CMTS), New Delhi .

Hutchison Essar Ltd., Mumbai,

Hutishson Telecom East Ltd., Kolkata and

Reliance Telecom Ltd., Gujarat .

12TH MAY, 2009 
25

Appeal No.5 of  2008     

(With M.A.No.114 of 2008)

Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd., New Delhi .

Vs.

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India , New Delhi ,

Association of Unified Telecom Service Providers of

India (AUSPI), New Delhi ,

Reliance Communications Ltd., New Delhi ,

Tata Teleservices Ltd., New Delhi  

HFCL Infotel Ltd., Punjab .

Cellular Operators Association of India , New Delhi ,

Bharti Airtel Ltd., New Delhi ,

Vodafone Essar Mobile Service Ltd., New Delhi ,

Idea Cellular Ltd., Gandhinagar,

BPL Mobile Communications Ltd., Mumbai

 and Spice Communications Ltd., New Delhi

12TH MAY, 2009 
26

Appeal No.4 of 2006

(With M.A.No.123 of 2006)

Cellular Operators Association of India , New Delhi ,

Aircel Ltd., Teynampet, Chennai,

BPL Mobile Cellular Ltd., Coimbatore ,

Bharti Televentures Ltd., New Delhi ,

Idea Cellular Ltd., Gandhinagar,

Hutchison Essar Mobile Services Ltd., New Delhi ,

Spice Communications Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi

and Reliance Telecom Ltd., Gujarat .

Vs.

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India , New Delhi

12TH MAY, 2009 
27 Petition No.265(C) of 2006

Hathway Nashik Cable Pvt. Ltd., Gurudwara Road , Nashik.

Vs.

Super Cable Network, Bhagwanpura, Nashik

 
28 Petition No.266 (C) of 2006

Hathway Nashik Cable Pvt. Ltd., Gurudwara Road , Nashik

Vs.

Swastik Cable Network, Panchavati, Nashik.

12TH MAY, 2009 
29 Petition No. 209 of 2006

M/s Reliance Infocomm Ltd., New Delhi .

Vs.

Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd., New Delhi .

11TH MAY, 2009 
30 Petition No. 256 (c) of 2006

Hathway Nashik Cable Pvt. Ltd., Gurudwara Road , Nashik

Vs

Cidco Cable Network, Cidco, Nashik

11TH MAY, 2009 
31 Petition No. 259 (c) of 2006

Hathway Nashik Cable Pvt. Ltd., Gurudwara Road , Nashik

                                    Vs

M.K. Cable Network, Indira Nagar , Nashik

11TH MAY, 2009 
32 Petition No. 260(C) of 2006

Hathway Nashik Cable Pvt. Ltd., Gurudwara Road , Nashik

Vs.

Cidco Cable Network, Adarsh Nagar , Cidco, Nashik

11TH MAY, 2009 
33 Petition No.261(C) of 2006

Hathway Nashik Cable Pvt. Ltd., Gurudwara Road , Nashik

Vs.

Vision Cable Network, Dwarka, Nashik

11TH MAY, 2009 
34 Petition No.267(C) of 2006

Hathway Nashik Cable Pvt. Ltd., Gurudwara Road , Nashik

Vs.

Vicky Cable Network, Old Cidco, Nashik

11TH MAY, 2009 
35 Petition No. 224 of 2006

M/s Reliance Infocomm Ltd., New Delhi .

Vs.

Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd., New Delhi .

5TH MAY, 2009 
36 Petition No.156 (C) of 2007

Manthan Broadband Services Pvt. Ltd., Kolkata.

Vs.

Akarshan Cable TV Network, Kolkata

5TH MAY, 2009 
37

Petition No.181 © of 2008

(With M.A .No. 6 of 2009)

Hathway Cable & Datacom Pvt.Ltd., New Delhi and

Star Vision Cable Network, Lucknow

Vs.

MSM Discovery Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi

4TH MAY, 2009 
38

Petition No. 73 (C)of 2008

  Along with

Petition No. 4 (C)  of 2009

(Appeal No.837 of 2003

Transferred from High Court ofBombay )

 

M/s Music Broadcast Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai.

Vs.

Union of India , New Deflhi.

 

Union of India

Vs.

M/s Music Broadcast Pvt. Ltd.

29TH APRIL, 2009 
39 Petition No. 321(C)of 2006

R.G. Gupta and Sons, Kadma, Jharkhand

Vs.

M/s Sunny Cable TV Network, Jameshdpur, Purbi Singhbhum

17TH APRIL, 2009
40

Petition No. 322  (C) of 2006

(With MA No.184 of 2008)

R.G. Gupta and Sons, Kadma, Jharkhand

Vs.

M/s Manoj Cable Network, Purbi Singhbhum, Jharkhand

17TH APRIL, 2009
41 Petition No. 323  (C) of 2006

R.G. Gupta and Sons, Kadma, Jharkhand

Vs.

M/s Jay Shree Interprises, Purbi Singhbhum, Jharkhand

17TH APRIL, 2009
42

Petition No. 286 of  2007 

(with M.A.Nos. 145 , 162 of 2007 & 27 of 2008)

Cellular Operatiors Association of India and Ors, New Delhi .
Bharti Airtel Limited, New Delhi .
Idea Cellular Limited, New Delhi .
Spice Communication Limited, Noida.
Vodafone Essar Limited, Mumbai.

Vs.

Union of India , New Delhi and
Telecom Regulatory Authority  of India , New Delhi ,
Reliance Communications Ltd, New Delhi ,
HFCL Infotel Ltd, New Delhi, Tata Teleservices Ltd,New Delhi ,
Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd, New Delhi ,
Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Ltd, New Delhi ,
Shyam Tellink Ltd, New Delhi , and  
Mr. Anish Puri & Others,  Delhi .

31ST MARCH, 2009  
43

Petition No. 168 of

2007

Spectrum Softee Solution(P)Ltd., Cochin

Vs.

General Manager, Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd, Kollam Kerala

25th MARCH, 2009
44

MA No.158 of 2008 in

Petition No.62(C) of 2008

Sun Direct TV Pvt. Ltd., Chennai

Vs.

MSM Discovery Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai

12TH FEBRUARY, 2009  
45 Appeal No.8 of 2007

Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd., New Delhi

                                    Vs.

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India , New Delhi.

23TH JANUARY, 2009  
46 Appeal No.9 of 2007

Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Ltd., New Delhi

                                 Vs.

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India , New Delhi.

23TH JANUARY, 2009  
47

Appeal No. 10 © of 2007

Set Discovery Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi.

                        Vs.

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India,                New Delhi,

IndusInd Media Communications Ltd., Andheri (East) Mumbai and

Hathway Cable  Datacom (P) Ltd., Shanta Cruz, Mumbai

15TH JANUARY, 2009 
48

Appeal No. 11© of 2007

Zee Turner Ltd., New Delhi.

                       Vs.

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India,                  New Delhi,  

IndusInd Media Communications Ltd. Andheri (East) Mumbai and   Hathway Cable and Datacom (P) Ltd., New Delhi.

15TH JANUARY, 2009 
49

Appeal No. 12 © of 2007

Star India Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai.

                        Vs.

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India, New Delhi, Hathway Cable and Datacom (P) Ltd., New Delh

IndusInd Media Communications Ltd., Andheri (East) Mumbai.

15TH JANUARY, 2009 
50 Appeal No.9 © of 2006(With M.A.No.103of 2007)

MSO Alliance, Industrial Area, Delhi and Indusind Media and Communications Ltd., Andheri (East), Mumbai.  

Vs.

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India,  New Delhi,   

Ministry of Information and Broadcasting,   New Delhi,  

M/s. Star India Pvt Ltd., Mumbai,

Set Discovery Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai,  

Zee, Mumbai,

ESPN Software Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai,

ESPN Software Pvt. Ltd., Delhi,  

Sahara India TV Network, Mumbai,   

Sahara Corporate Office, Mumbai,

BBC World, Mumbai,

BBC World, Delhi, 

B4U, Mumbai, 

ETV,  Mumbai,

ETV, Hyderabad,

Sun TV/Gemini TV/Udaya, Chennai,

Raj Television Network Ltd., Chennai and 

MAA Television Network Ltd., Hyderabad.

15TH JANUARY, 2009 
51 Appeal No. 13 © of 2007 (With M.A.No.155 of 2007)

Intermedia Cable Communication Pvt. Ltd., Pune.

                        Vs.

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India,

New Delhi.

15TH JANUARY, 2009 
52 Appeal No. 15 © of 2007

Sun TV Network Ltd., Chennai.

                          Vs.

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India, New Delhi.

15TH JANUARY, 2009 
53 Petition No.215 © of 2008

Wire and Wireless ( India ) ltd., New Delhi

                               Vs.

M/s. MSM Set Discovery, New Delhi

7TH JANUARY, 2009