||दूरसंचार विवाद समाधान एवं अपील अधिकरण ||
Telecom Disputes Settlement and Appellate Tribunal (TDSAT)
||सत्यमेव जयते||
NEW DELHI

JUDGEMENTS / ORDERS - 2007

 

S.No Appeal/Petition

Description/Case Title

Date of decision
1 Petition No.91© of 2006

ESPN Software India Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi

Vs.

Intermedia Cable Communication Pvt. Ltd., Pune, Maharashtra

3RD DECEMBER, 2007
2 E.A. No. 21 of 2007 in Appeal No. 14 of 2006

Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd.

                  Vs.

Telecom Regulatory of India , New Delhi ,

Cellular Operators Association of India , New Delhi ,

Aircel Ltd. Chennai.

BPL Mobile Cellular Ltd. Coimbatore ,

Bharti Airtel Ltd. New Delhi .

Idea Cellular Ltd. Gandhinagar,

Hutchison Essar Mobile Services Ltd. New Delhi,

Spice Communications Pvt.Ltd. New Delhi and

Reliance Telecom Ltd. Gujarat

28TH NOVEMBER, 2007
3

Petition No.125 of 2005

 

 

 

Bharti Televentures Ltd.

Vs.

Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd.,

Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Ltd. and

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India

 

14TH SEPTEMBER, 2007
4

Petition No. 253 (C) of 2006

Sri Gowthami Network, A P

Vs.

Channel Plues – A P, Chennai

 

14TH SEPTEMBER, 2007
5

Petition No.4 © of 2007

Millenium Delhi Broadcast Pvt. Ltd., Worli, Mumbai

Vs.

Union of India, through

Secretary, Ministry of Information & Broadcasting, New Delhi and Secretary, Ministry of Communications, New Delhi

 

14TH SEPTEMBER, 2007
6

Petition No.5 © of 2007

Millenium Chennai Broadcast Pvt. Ltd., Worli, Mumbai

Vs.

Union of India, through

Secretary, Ministry of Information & Broadcasting, New Delhi and Secretary, Ministry of Communications, New Delhi

14TH SEPTEMBER, 2007
7

R.A. No. 11 of 2007 in Petition No. 7 of 2003

 

 

Association of Unified Telecom Service Providers of India, New Delhi,

Tata Teleservices (MH) Ltd., Shyam Telelink Ltd., New Delhi,

Tata Teleservices Ltd., New Delhi and

HFCL Infotel Ltd., New Delhi

Vs

Union of India, New Delhi,

Asst. Director General (LF-I), New Delhi, and

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India, New Delhi

 

14TH SEPTEMBER, 2007
8

R.A. No. 12 of 2007 in Petition No.   81   of 2005

The Arvind Mills Ltd. (Telecom Division), Ahmedabad

Vs.

Department of Telecommunications, New Delhi and

Bank of Baroda, Ahmedabad

 

14TH SEPTEMBER, 2007
9

R.A. No. 10 of 2007 in Petition No.82 of 2005

Cellular Operators Association of India, New Delhi,

Aircel Ltd., Chennai,

Aircel Cellular Ltd., Chennai,

Bharti Cellular Ltd., New Delhi,

Hutchison Telecom East Ltd., Kolkata and

IDEA Celluar Ltd., New Delhi

Vs.

Union of India, New Delhi and

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India

 

14TH SEPTEMBER, 2007
10

R.A. No. 8 of 2007 In Petition No.293(C) of 2006

Bhaskar Cable Network, Jabalpur, M.P.

Vs.

M/s Zee-Turner Ltd., New Delhi/Shahpura, Bhopal

 

7TH SEPTEMBER, 2007
11

Petition No. 20 of 2002

 

Hughes Escorts Communication Ltd. New Delhi

Vs.

Union of India, ND

5TH SEPTEMBER, 2007
12

Petition No.146

of 2005

 

M/s Bharti Televentures Ltd., New Delhi

Vs.

Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd., New Delhi

 

5TH SEPTEMBER, 2007
13

R.A. No.7  of 2007

In

Petition No.293(C)

of 2006 (R.A. No. 8 of 2007)

Bhaskar Cable Network, Jabalpur , M.P.

Vs.

M/s Zee-Turner Ltd., New Delhi/Shahpura,Bhopal

 

3RD SEPTEMBER, 2007
14

Petition No. 7 of 2003

(M.A. Nos. 2/04 and 95, 103, 114, 117 & 122 of 2006, respectively) 

 

 

Association of Unified Telecom Service Providers of India, New Delhi,

Tata Teleservices (MH) Ltd., Shyam Telelink Ltd., New Delhi,

Tata Teleservices Ltd., New Delhi and

HFCL Infotel Ltd., New Delhi

Vs

Union of India, New Delhi,

Asst. Director General (LF-I), New Delhi, and

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India, New Delhi

 

30TH AUGUST, 2007
15

Petition No.53 of 2004

(With M.A. No.45 of 2006)

Data Access ( India ) Ltd., New Delhi

Vs.

Department of Telecommunications,New Delhi

 

30TH AUGUST, 2007
16

Petition No.  81   of 2005

The Arvind Mills Ltd. (Telecom Division), Ahmedabad

Vs.

Department of Telecommunications,New Delhi and

Bank of Baroda , Ahmedabad

30TH AUGUST, 2007
17

Petition No.82 of 2005

Cellular Operators Association of India ,New Delhi ,

Aircel Ltd., Chennai,

Aircel Cellular Ltd., Chennai,

Bharti Cellular Ltd., New Delhi ,

Hutchison Telecom East Ltd., Kolkata and

IDEA Celluar Ltd., New Delhi

Vs.

Union of India , New Delhi and

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India

 

30TH AUGUST, 2007
18

Petition No.98 of 2005

(M A No. 148 of 2006)

 

M/s Bharti Broadband Ltd., Navi Mumbai

Vs.

Department of Telecommunications, New Delhi

 

30TH AUGUST, 2007
19

Petition No.48 of 2005

(With M.A. Nos. 131 of 2005 and 28 of 2006)

Videsh Sanchar Nigam Ltd., Mumbai

Vs.

Union of India , New Delhi and

Deputy Director General (LF-I), New Delhi

 

30TH AUGUST, 2007
20

Petition No.59 of 2005

Videsh Sanchar Nigam Ltd., Mumbai

Vs.

Union of India , New Delhi and

Deputy Director General (LF-I), New Delhi

 

30TH AUGUST, 2007
21

Petition No.   57 of 2006

(With MA No. 104 of 2007)

Hughes Escorts Communications Ltd., New Delhi .

Vs.

Union of India , New Delhi and

Assistant Director General (LF-1), Deptt of Telecommunications, Delhi

 

30TH AUGUST, 2007
22

Petition No.102 of 2006

VSAT Services Association of India (VSAI),New Delhi

Vs.

Union of India , New Delhi

 

30TH AUGUST, 2007
23

Petition No. 119 of 2006

Internet Service Providers Association ofIndia (ISPAI), New Delhi ,

C J Online Pvt. Ltd., Ghaziabad ,

Deldsl Internet Pvt. Ltd, Delhi

Exatt Techologiey Pvt. Ltd, Andheri (W), Mumbai,

Estel Communication Pvt. Ltd., Gurgaon,

Hathway Cable & Datacom Pvt. Ltd., Santacruz (W), Mumbai,

Icenet Net Ltd., Ahmedabad, 

Netmagic Soulutions Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai,

Primus Telecommunications India Ltd.,Delhi ,

Reach Network India Pvt. Ltd. Guregaon (E), Mumbai, 

Tulip IT Services Ltd. New Delhi ,

World Phone Internet Services Pvt. Ltd.New Delhi , 

Trak Online Net India Pvt. Ltd, New Delhi ,

Pacific Internet India Pvt. Ltd., Worli, Mumbai,

Iqara Telecoms India Pvt. Ltd., Goregaon (E) Mumbai, 

Vebtel Obconic Internet Protocol Pvt. Ltd.,Hyderabad , 

Tata Internet Services Ltd.

Vs

Union of India , New Delhi

 

30TH AUGUST, 2007
24

Appeal No. 14 of 2006 (M.A. No.134 of 2006)

 

Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd., New Delhi

Vs.

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India , New Delhi ,

Cellular Operators Association of India, New Delhi, Aircel Ltd., Teynampet, Chennai,

BPL Mobile Cellular Ltd., Coimbatore, Bharti Airtel Ltd., New Delhi, Idea Cellular Ltd., Gandhinagar,

Hutchison Essar Mobile Services Ltd., New Delhi,

Spice Communications Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi and

Reliance Telecom Ltd., Dist. Jamnagar , Gujrat and

Asssociation of Unified Telecom Service Providers of India (AUSPI), Reliance Infocomm Ltd., Tata Teleservices Ltd., Tata Teleservices (Maharashtra) Ltd.

 

24TH AUGUST, 2007
25

Appeal No.16 of 2006

Cellular Operators Association of India , New Delhi ,

Aircel Ltd., Teynampet, Chennai,

BPL Mobile Cellular Ltd., Coimbatore ,

Bharti Airtel Ltd., New Delhi ,

Birla AT & T Communications Ltd., Gandhinagar,

Hutchison

Essar Mobile Services Ltd., New Delhi ,

Spice Communications Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi ,

Reliance Telecom Ltd., Gujrat,

Fascel Ltd., Ahmedabad,

Hutchison Essar South Ltd., New Delhi ,

Aircell Digilink India Ltd., New Delhi ,

Hutchison Telecom East Ltd., Kolkata,

Hutchison Essar Cellular Ltd., Coimbatore ,

BPL Mobile communications Ltd., Kochi ,

Dishnet Wireless Ltd., Chennai,

Aircel Cellular Ltd., Chennai and

Bharti Hexacom Ltd., New Delhi

Vs.

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India , New Delhi and

Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd., New Delhi and

 

24TH AUGUST, 2007
26

Petition No.319 of 2006

Cellular Operators Association of India , New Delhi ,

Aircel Ltd., Teynampet, Chennai,

BPL Mobile Cellular Ltd., Coimbatore ,

Bharti Airtel Ltd., New Delhi ,

Birla AT & T Communications Ltd., Gandhinagar,

Hutchison

Essar Mobile Services Ltd., New Delhi ,

Spice Communications Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi ,

Reliance Telecom Ltd., Gujrat,

Fascel Ltd., Ahmedabad,

Hutchison Essar South Ltd., New Delhi ,

Aircell Digilink India Ltd., New Delhi ,

Hutchison Telecom East Ltd., Kolkata,

Hutchison Essar Cellular Ltd., Coimbatore ,

BPL Mobile communications Ltd., Kochi ,

Dishnet Wireless Ltd., Chennai,

Aircel Cellular Ltd., Chennai and

Bharti Hexacom Ltd., New Delhi

Vs.

Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd., New Delhi and

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India , New Delhi

24TH AUGUST, 2007
27 Petition No. 229 (C) of 2006

Indusind Media and Communications Ltd.  Mumbai

Vs.

Zee Turner ltd., New Delhi

3.7. 2007
28 Appeal No. 1 (C) of 2007

M/s NEO Sports Broadcast Pvt. Ltd.,

Andheri West Mumbai

Vs.

TRAI, New Delhi

3.7. 2007
29 Appeal No.3(C) of 2007

Grahak Hitvardhini Sarvajanik Sanstha, Pune

Vs.

The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India , New Delhi and

Nimbus Sports Broadcast Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai

3.7. 2007
30 Petition No.157(C) of 2006

Hathway Media Vision Pvt. Ltd.

formerly known as

“United Cable Network Pvt. Ltd.”

having its registered office at:

‘Rahejas’, 4th Floor Corner of

Main Avenue & V.P. Road

Santacruz (W)

Mumbai – 400 054                                              

  Versus

Mr.Shabbir Shaikh

B.L.D.J. Police Camp

Room No.75, Ground Floor

Worli Police Camp

Mumbai – 400 018                        

22.05.2007
31 Petition No.133(C) of 2006

Hathway Media Vision Pvt. Ltd.

formerly known as

“United Cable Network Pvt. Ltd.”

having its registered office at:

‘Rahejas’, 4th Floor Corner of

Main Avenue & V.P. Road

Santacruz (W)

Mumbai – 400 054                                                               

Versus

M/s Silver Star Cable Network through Mr.Shakeel Shaikh

Sole Proprietor

Room No.17 # 10,

Worli Police Camp

Mumbai – 400 018       

22.05.2007
32 Petition No.293(C) of  2006

Bhaskar Cable Network

Through its General Manager

Mr. Gurdeep Singh Saini

581, South Civil Lines,

Jabalpur

Madhya Pradesh                                                                                        

 

    Vs.

 

M/s Zee Turner  Limited

5th Floor, Radisson Plaza,

NH-8, New Delhi-110037  

15.05 2007
34 Petition No.133(C) of 2005

M/s.Khammam Popular Communications,

D.No.10-2-78, Mayuri Centre,

Bus Depot Road,

Khamman,

Andhra Pradesh-507001

Through Syed Sadiq Ali …Petitioner

Versus

1. M/s. Channel Plus-AP,

No.367/369, Anna Salai,

Teynampet,

Chennai-600018.

2. M/s. Sri Sai Communications

10-2-78, Mayuri Centre,

Khamman-507001.

3. M/s. Maruti Satellite Services

Professional Plaza, Mayuri Centre,

Khamman, Andhra Pradesh-507001.

30.4. 2007
35 Petition No.227(C) of 2006

National Cable Network     

Sirhindi Gate, Malerkotla

District Sangrur, Punjab 

Through its Manager Mr. Gopal Krishan                                      …Petitioner

 

Vs.

 

1.  SET Discovery Pvt. Ltd.

     2nd Floor, 9/1B, Secular House,

     Qutab Institutional Area

     Aruna Asaf Ali Marg, New Delhi-110067                        

 

2.   Zee Turner Ltd.

      5th Floor, Radisson Plaza

      NH-8, New Delhi-110 037

 

3.   Alliance Cable @ Malwa Cable

      Back side, Stadium Ground

      Near Income Tax Office

      Malerkotla, District-Sangrur,

      Punjab-148023

12.04.2007

36 Petition No.189(C) of 2006

Tata Sky Limited

3rd Floor, Bombay Dyeing,

A.O. Building,

Pandurang Budhkar Marg,

Worli, Mumbai – 400 025                                                                                                                                   

Versus

 

1.         Zee Turner Limited,

            5th Floor, Radisson Plaza,

            National Highway-8

            New Delhi – 110 037                                                                

 

2          Zee Telefilms Limited,

135, Continental Bldg.,

Dr. Anne Besant Road,

Worli, Mumbai – 400 018                                                    

 

3.         Turner International India Pvt.Ltd.,

            S-2 Level, Block-F,

            International Trade Tower,

            Nehru Place,

            New Delhi-110019                                                             

 

4.         ASC Enterprises Limited,

            J-27, South Extension-I,

            New Delhi-110 049.                                                            

 

 

31.03.2007
37 Petition No.39(C) of 2004

Star India Private Limited

Vs

M/s Asianet Satellite Communications Private Limited

30.03.2007
38 Petition No.39(C) of 2006

Zee Turner Limited

Vs.

A.M.Trinity Platco Limited.

26.03.2007
39 Petition No.148 of 2005

BPL Mobile Communications Limited

Vs.

Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Limited
19.03.2007
40 Petition No.218 of 2006

M/s Reliance Infocomm Ltd., New Delhi

Vs.

1. The Chairman & Managing Director, MTNL, New Delhi.

2. The Executive Director, MTNL, New Delhi and

3. The Executive Director, MTNL, Mumbai
19.03.2007
41 Appeal No.10(C) of 2006 with Appeal No.12(C0 of 2006 & Appeal No.13(C) of 2006

SET Discovery Pvt. Ltd.

Vs.

TRAI & Ors.

WITH

M/s ESPN Star Sports & Anr.

Vs.

TRAI & Ors.

And

M/s ESPN Star Sports & Anr.

Vs.

TRAI & Ors.

27.02.2007